Democrats fell short of the required 60-votes to pass a bill that would have allowed the Secretary of HHS the power to negotiate Medicare Part D drug prices. Democrats did get 55 votes while 42 Senators opposed the bill. The vote generally followed party lines.
The Medicare Part D drug negotiation bill was little more than a political charade anyway since the bill would not give HHS any leverage in negotiating Medicare Part D drug prices. Unless Medicare has the right to exclude a drug from coverage under Medicare, there isn't any reason for a drug manufacturer to lower their price. The lack of any negotiating leverage made this a pretty hollow bill.
If the bill had passed and been combined with a similar (and just as hollow) House bill, President Bush would have vetoed it making this a just a political exercise.
Even though this was a very weak bill, the pharmaceutical industry pulled out all of the stops to kill it. Their worry was that even this weak bill could have been manipulated by regulation into something more powerful by a future Democratic Secretary of HHS. If nothing else, it also represented the "camel's nose under the tent" since it could have served as the basis of an expansion by a more liberal Congress and President down the road.
Ironically, private Medicare Part D insurance companies have this leverage--they can exclude a particular manufacturers product (although they must include drugs from every class) or place it in a co-pay tier that puts it at a disadvantage from competitors drugs. That leverage makes it possible for insurers to get lower prices.
You can also hear my Wednesday evening comments on public radio's "Marketplace:" Medicare Drug Bill Stalls
My January comments on the House drug negotiation bill: The Democrats Hollow Part D Proposal
A Health Care Reform Blog––Bob Laszewski's review of the latest developments in federal health policy, health care reform, and marketplace activities in the health care financing business.
Subscribe
Avoid having to check back.
Subscribe to Health Care Policy and Marketplace Review and receive an email each time we post.
Blog Archive
-
▼
2007
(235)
-
▼
April
(17)
- The Carnival of Risk # 24 is Up
- Humana Caps Annual Increases on Consumer-Driven Pl...
- The Medicare Fee-For-Service Product is a Kamikaze...
- Medicare Drug Negotiation Bill Fails in the Senate
- Latest "Health Wonk Review" is Up
- Hillary Clinton Doesn't Like Health Insurance Comp...
- Democratic Presidential Candidate Bill Richardson ...
- The Imus Fiasco and the Virginia Tech Massacre—Wha...
- Senate Developments on Medicare Advantage Payments...
- More Than 10 Million Are Now Using Consumer-Driven...
- Another Victory Declared in Massachusetts--The Con...
- The Medicare Part D Drug Benefit: "The Ugliest Nig...
- A Bipartisan Bill to Ban Genetic Discrimination Co...
- A Drug Reimportation Bill Continues to Receive Bip...
- A Mental Health Parity Bill Still on Track for Pas...
- The Health Wonk Review--A New and Improved U.S. He...
- The Real Reason Health Care Reform is Hard—Hillary...
-
▼
April
(17)